The book is divided into
three main sections; "The Genesis of a Circus," "The Hour of Truth," and "Already an Empire"
with each section subdivided into many chapters, each being only one to five pages in length,
independently covering the different aspects of Cirque du Soleil's development. The chapters
barely scratch the surface of the topics they cover and although they are more-or-less
presented in chronological order they are written as disjoint, self-contained pieces creating
some narrative flow problems which, combined with the author's cross-cutting between different
times, places, people and events, results in laborious reading. "In the Wings of the Cirque
du Soleil" reads more like a collection of newspaper clippings than a book. It wouldn't
exactly be a compelling book for a casual reader but it is reasonably informative for those
ardent fans of Cirque du Soleil.
It should be noted that book is clearly written for a Québec audience. Though it is due
to be published in English later this year the translation will only allow for an understanding
of the text. For a thorough comprehension of the subject matter, those who are unfamiliar
with La Belle Province will need to do some additional homework. The fact that the story of
the Cirque du Soleil is set within the history and political climate of 20th century Québec
is taken for granted.
[
Therefore, if a reader is unaware of the significance of events and people such as Jacques
Cartier, the Quiet Revolution, Expo '67, the 1976 Olympic Games, René Lévesque, the October
Crisis, the 1980 Referendum on Sovereignty or the unique cultural differences of Québec in
general, he or she may want to look in some history books in order to thoroughly establish
the setting of the story. Also, if the reader can't tell Charlevoix from Sherbrooke, an
Atlas will help establish the different locations.
As is the case with any "unauthorized" tell-all, the credibility of the account is never
assured. The reader must take the information presented with a grain of salt and consider
the biases of the author and those whom he interviews. At best the book provides an
alternate view of the organization to counter the corporate propaganda produced by the
company itself in the form of shamelessly indulgent, self-promoting "documentaries" such
as "A Baroque Odyssey" and "Run Before You Fly." In either case it is pertinent that
the reader/viewer processes the information presented with a critical mind, realizing that
both versions are only half-truths. The trick becomes deciding which half to believe.
Some of the book's more interesting "revelations" about the company include:
Guy Laliberté
The main character of Cirque du Soleil's story is Guy Laliberté whom the author
alternately deifies and vilifies throughout the course of the account.
Born on September 2, 1959, Guy was a member of an affluent middle-class Québec City
family. Guy's father Gaston was the vice-president of Alcan (Canada's largest Aluminum
company) and his mother Blandine was a nurse. Always rambunctious and filled with
wanderlust Guy ran away from home at the age of 14 leaving behind a note to his parents
with a quote from philosopher Kahlil Gibran, "Your children are not your children; they
are the sons and daughters of the call of life itself." Guy traveled the world living
life under the hippie philosophy. He played accordion on the streets for money. He
traveled to Europe with nothing more than his accordion and $50 in his pocket. He often
slept on park benches in Paris and London at the time. Guy also wound up in Hawaii for
a while, where he picked up the art of fire-eating.
Much to his parents' relief Guy eventually returned home after his stab at
independence. He even agreed to take a job at a hydro-electric installation at
James Bay with the intention of saving enough money to pursue a degree in Nuclear
Engineering. Three days before he was to begin work the workers went on strike
and the site was closed. In a twist of fate which Laliberté later said changed
the course of his life he decided to spend the summer at the Fête Foraine, the
busker festival in Baie-Saint-Paul where he met Gilles Ste. Croix and his Stiltwalkers
of Baie-Saint-Paul; a meeting that would eventually lead to the formation of the
Cirque du Soleil many years later.
Government Grants
In 1984 the governments of Canada and Québec invested large amounts of money to
put on a celebration commemorating the 450th anniversary of the arrival of Jacques
Cartier in Québec. When Québec's minister of Cultural Affairs refused to fund Guy
Laliberté's idea of a Quebecois circus, Guy, already showing the candor and business
savvy that would characterize him in future years, went over the Minister's head
straight to the Premiere of Québec, René Lévesque. Guy negotiated a $1.4 million
grant from Lévesque to present his show in 11 cities across the province of Québec
in the summer of 1984.
Le Grand Tour
With an 800-seat big top the newly formed Cirque du Soleil traipsed around Québec
in the summer of 1984. Tickets for the very first Cirque du Soleil show cost $2.00
for adults, $1.00 for children. The Cirque was the runaway hit of the summer
festival and the reception Cirque received was phenomenal, in Québec city a riot
nearly broke out when a crowd of 4000 showed up when there were only 800 tickets to
be had for the performance.
The original government funding was to last only for the summer of 1984, after
which the Cirque du Soleil was supposed to have finished its mandate to perform at
the 450th anniversary festivities and quietly folded. Guy of course would have
none of it and again convinced René Lévesque to fund a second tour the following
summer. This tour would be the Cirque's first outside their home province. They
would play larger markets in Ontario. However, this first excursion outside Québec
proved to be a near-catastrophe. Marketing itself as the "Sun Circus" the troupe
started to perform in Canada's most populous city, Toronto, only to have hoards of
disappointed spectators demanding refunds feeling cheated because their "circus"
did not feature any animals!
Niagara Falls is one of the world's prime tourist destinations but of the millions
who came to see the falls each year, very few were interested in attending the
performances of the "Sun Circus;" the troupe was playing to nearly empty houses. If
they sold fewer than 65 tickets for a given evening's performance, the show would not
go on; half of the scheduled performances were canceled as a result.
Behind the scenes, conditions were dire. Low morale and rampant drug use permeated
the group of artists. On the verge of a mutiny, Guy called upon Normand Latourelle an
organizing committee member of the 450th anniversary festival and asked for his help.
The company was in serious debt.
To salvage the failing company Guy negotiated another Government grant from René
Lévesque and brought the show back to Montreal to finish the season.
Los Angeles Festival
With the goal of changing the Cirque du Soleil from a not-for-profit organization
reliant on government subsidies to a profitable enterprise Guy Laliberté knew that he
had to risk the whole of his company on success in the United States. A circus troupe
cannot be run profitably if it played only in Québec or only in Canada because the
climate would only allow for performances a maximum of 6-months during the year.
After a successful Canadian tour of Cirque's second show La Magie Continue, Guy
would risk it all by bringing the company's new show Le Cirque Réinventé (We Reinvent
the Circus) to the Los Angeles Times Theatre Festival. As the now-famous story goes,
it was a make-or-break scenario; if the run in Los Angeles failed the company would
not have enough money for gas to bring their equipment back. Although contrary to the
legend, the heavy equipment and big top was actually transported by train and not by
truck. The company's dilapidated trucks of the time would not likely have survived
the cross-continent trek.
The Cirque du Soleil became a smash hit and took Los Angeles by storm. It went
from virtual obscurity to become the must-see show of the festival and the audience
was full of movie stars and Hollywood big shots.
Growing Pains
After Cirque du Soleil exploded onto the scene at the Los Angeles Festival it went
on to conquer America beginning its exponential growth phase. Guy Laliberté became
the quintessential playboy, with his newfound wealth he bought a Porsche and was often
seen in the company of supermodels. His "delinquent" tendencies continued as he would
often disappear for long spells of time. Meanwhile, all was not well backstage. The
company's newfound wealth did not trickle down to the artists who still toiled
thanklessly sometimes performing seven shows in a 54 hour span of time. After
presenting "Réinventé" over 300 times, fatigue and ennui set in with the cast members
coupled with resentment of the company's upper management who benefited immediately
from the Cirque's rapid success but "failed to send the elevator back down to the
artists."
Cirque's star contortionist Angela Laurier expressed her concerns about Cirque
abandoning its integrity and original spirit in an on-camera interview for the film
"A Circus in America" directed by La Presse reporter Natalie Petrowski, "Now everybody
is more individualized. The Cirque isn't the same as it was before. It's much more
disciplined and more about performance than in the past. This worries me, by growing
too fast the Cirque risks losing its originality, its spirit . . I feel like I'm
distancing myself from my values. The artists feel ill-at-ease in their own skin
because of stress. At the beginning it was about exploration of a circus but now
it's just a routine."
Guy Laliberté certainly did not appreciate the critique of his company from an
insider and chose not to renew Angela Laurier's performance contract. Natalie
Petrowski is shunned by Laliberté to this day; she was never again granted an
interview and was effectively banned from the Varekai premiere.
Franco Dragone
Indisputably the Cirque du Soleil's most prolific creator, Franco Dragone was
born in 1952 in Caraino, Italy (close to Naples), Dragone's family relocated to
Louvière, Belgium in 1959. For 10 years beginning in 1968 Dragone performed with
la Compagnie du Campus, a fringe Belgian theatre troupe that performed shows with
social and political themes. After meeting Guy Caron, Dragone came to Montreal
and fell in love with the city. It was there he discovered his vocation as a
theatre director. His first Cirque du Soleil production was La Magie Continue.
Cirque Director of Creation Gilles Ste-Croix described Franco's unique gift; "He
searches within each performer to find his theatrical lever. He recreates you
into a character that is your own. That is his gift." Dragone left Cirque du
Soleil in 1987 after directing Le Cirque Réinventé feeling that the upper
management (namely Laliberté) encroached too much on his artistic freedom. Guy
Laliberté subsequently lured him back to the Cirque fold in 1989 by offering to
give Dragone the post of Director of Creation, Research and Development and the
artistic freedoms that go along with it. Dragone accepted and created Nouvelle
Éxperience and every subsequent Cirque show until 1998 when he was rumored to
have suffered a mild, stress-induced heart attack while concurrently creating
"O" and "La Nouba" after which he left Cirque du Soleil on amicable terms.
Management Crises: Laliberté, Gauthier, Latourelle
The direction of the Cirque du Soleil has always been a tumultuous and
fractious affair. For much of its history the company had three main managers;
Guy Laliberté, Daniel Gauthier and Normand Latourelle.
Daniel Gauthier was a wiser man of fewer excesses than Guy Laliberté. He was
competent manager and businessman. Normand Latourelle had extensive experience in
managing musical artists. He was business savvy and familiar with the entertainment
industry. In the early days the company was very much a three-headed monster and
there was much conflict with the management. In 1987 Latourelle was convinced
that the success of the company depended on the removal of Guy Laliberté Daniel
Gauthier originally agreed and the two planned an ouster of Laliberté. Gauthier
later reneged, citing Guy's newly negotiated contracts for performances in Las
Vegas and in the end it was Latourelle who was written out of the story.
In the year 2000, Gauthier himself would leave Cirque. Though the circumstances
of his departure are not entirely certain, it is widely believed that Gauthier did
not agree with Laliberté's plans at the time to invest in high-risk ventures such
as the Cirque entertainment complexes combined with fact that the shift of focus
away from live shows, due in part to the departure of Dragone, meant the company
was not growing in the direction he would have liked. In 2000, the Cirque's net
worth was $800 million. Guy Laliberté bought Gauthier out for the amount of $483
million. Most of the Cirque's net worth was in its physical property so Laliberté
had to borrow a large (undisclosed) amount to complete the transaction. Hence,
Guy Laliberté became the Cirque du Soleil's sole owner and authority.
Steve Wynn
Steve Wynn is widely credited as the visionary who re-invented Las Vegas and
opened the door for Cirque du Soleil, first by bringing Nouvelle Expérience to town
for a gig at his Mirage Resort and then by building a permanent theatre in his
Treasure Island Resort to house Mystère after Caesar's Palace turned down Cirque's
show idea dismissing it as "too esoteric" for Vegas.
Wynn is an unconventional entrepreneur; with an appreciation for fine art,
demonstrated by his impressive personal collection of works by Picasso, Renoir
and Cézanne, among others, it may not have seemed surprising that Wynn was the
first to welcome Cirque du Soleil to Sin City. However, before Mystère was to
debut in 1993 Wynn had his doubts and pressed to delay the premiere to rework
the show; "We've never seen anything like this in Vegas. What's the big idea
with the crying baby at the beginning of the show? What do you want to say to
the audience? It's not good for Las Vegas." Wynn also claimed that the show
was as heavy as a Wagner opera and that the Vegas cab drivers would crucify it.
For his part Dragone also harboured much reservation about working in Las Vegas,
Dragone was accustomed to directing street performances, and had devoted much of
his creative life promoting humanitarian causes. He was afraid that working in a
place as big and soullessly corporate as Las Vegas would require him to compromise
his integrity, essentially to sell-out; "At first I was ill-at-ease . . . I asked
myself, despite everything, how can I make a social gesture the heart of the Cirque
du Soleil? I had disguised myself as a show-business man to infiltrate showbiz.
[In my previous work] we wanted to highlight social problems on stage to build
solutions. With Cirque du Soleil my political concerns have been displaced: they're
no longer in the show but in the management. Cirque du Soleil's biggest social
action has been to create 2 500 jobs. However, I am adamant that each show carries
a message."
Mega-Resorts
Guy Laliberté, being the sole figurehead of the Cirque du Soleil, had ambitious
plans to expand the Cirque empire into other realms. In April of 2002 he appeared
before the Montreal Chamber of Commerce. Refusing to begin his speech until every
last business person in the room donned the red clown noses he brought, Guy presented
his vision of creating crazy hotels and integrated entertainment centers; "Cirque
Complexes" all over the world. He was presenting to the Chamber to ask for support
in creating the first prototype Cirque Complex in Montreal. Guy was well received
after giving an impassioned speech touching on sentiments of Québec nationalism and
Montreal civic pride. However, plans for the proposed Cirque Complexes would
eventually be scrubbed by the company. The Cirque's management saw Guy's plan as
"too risky in light of the world's current uncertainty" and thought concentrating
efforts on the company's live shows would be less risky and more profitable.
The Future
What insights does the author have about the future of Cirque du Soleil? Aside
from the oft-repeated concern that the company is growing too big too fast, Beaunoyer
speculates that the company will keep expanding into other areas such as multimedia,
hotels and cinema. However, he also presents a sobering possibility that Cirque
could one day be bought out by a big American corporation. He points to signs that
the Cirque has already become decentralized from Québec. Ultimately, the author
places his faith in Guy Laliberté and believes he will steer the company on course
for years to come.
Some other interesting tidbits can be found in the book such as the reason
France has been left out of Cirque's European tours until this year, the causes
behind the rise and fall of Gilles Ste-Croix's Cheval Théâtre or the fact that
even though Cirque du Soleil is championed by animal rights activists the original
reason for the exclusion of animal acts was purely pragmatic; "There are no animal
acts in our show at the time being but certain animal acts may be included in the
future if they can be incorporated into the spirit of our circus." Guy was quoted
as saying in Cirque's early days.
In Conclusion
Overall, the book wasn't nearly as interesting as I had anticipated. At times
I found the book's focus is too broad, Beaunoyer indulges in meandering detours
through Québec history, descriptions of all of Cirque's spin-off troupes and
editorials about Québec politics. Though intended to place the story in a firm
context, I found these excursions to be superfluous and distracting.
For those of us who have followed the company closely throughout its development
the book does not include as much new information as we would like, even the
"revelations" are all things we could have pretty much suspected to be true.
However, the book does serve as a nice chronicle of the history of the Cirque du
Soleil.
The book falls far short of being either a thorough piece of investigative
journalism or an engaging business case-study. It is ultimately unsatisfying
because of its overly-broad scope and meager details. Pick it up if you're really
interested in Cirque du Soleil's history but don't expect anything too in-depth
or intellectually engaging.